Contents
What’s it: Foreign portfolio investment refers to short-term investment in financial instruments (such as stocks and bonds) in another country. For purchases on the stock market, this investment does not give the investor direct control and ownership of the company’s assets.
Portfolio investment is one of the common ways to invest abroad, together with foreign direct investment. For destination countries, both are sources of loanable funds, which are important for increasing their productive capacity.
In national accounting, foreign portfolio investment is a component of capital accounts in the balance of payments. The balance of payments shows the amount of money flowing in and out of a country during a specific period, usually quarterly or one year. It consists of two current accounts and capital accounts.
Example of foreign portfolio investment
Portfolio investment involves buying securities on a foreign stock exchange. For instance, a US investor might purchase shares of a Chinese tech company listed on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange. These investments aim to generate returns quickly, either through capital gains (increase in share price), dividends (company payouts), or coupons (interest payments on bonds).
The variety of available securities depends on the development of a country’s capital market. In less developed markets, there might be fewer investment options.
Foreign investors often gravitate towards liquid assets, meaning they can be easily bought and sold. Examples include government bonds and established company stocks. These instruments may have a higher trading volume, allowing investors to enter and exit positions more readily.
The type of return an investor seeks influences their choices. For example, government bonds typically offer steady coupon payments, while stocks have the potential for higher capital gains but also carry more risk.
Since foreign portfolio investment involves two currencies, exchange rate fluctuations can impact the overall return. A strengthening foreign currency relative to the investor’s home currency can translate into additional gains, while a weakening currency can lead to losses.
Key differences between Foreign Portfolio Investment (FPI) and foreign direct investment (FDI)
While both FPI and FDI involve investing in foreign assets, both foreign investments differ significantly in several key areas:
Investment horizon
FPI: Think short-term. Investors can enter and exit positions in the foreign market quickly, aiming to capture returns within a shorter timeframe. This flexibility allows them to react to changes in market conditions or their investment goals.
FDI: Long-term commitment is the name of the game. FDI typically involves establishing a physical presence in a foreign country, such as a factory or office. This necessitates a longer-term investment horizon, often spanning several years or even decades.
Liquidity
FPI: Highly liquid assets are preferred. Investors favor easily tradable securities like stocks and bonds listed on major exchanges. This allows them to buy and sell their holdings quickly without significant difficulty.
FDI: Investments are often less liquid. Direct investments may involve building new infrastructure or acquiring existing businesses. These assets are not easily converted back into cash, making them less liquid compared to FPI holdings.
Control
FPI: Investors have minimal control. When purchasing shares of a foreign company, they don’t gain a say in its management decisions. Their influence is limited to the power of their vote at shareholder meetings, which is typically proportional to the number of shares owned (usually a minority stake).
FDI: Control is a central objective. The goal of FDI is often to gain a significant ownership stake in a foreign company, potentially even a majority stake. This allows the investor to exert significant influence over the company’s operations and strategic direction.
Risk
FPI: Generally considered lower risk. Investors primarily face market risks associated with stock price fluctuations and exchange rate movements. Business performance risks are typically borne by the companies they invest in, not the investors themselves.
FDI: Carries higher inherent risk. In addition to market risks, FDI exposes investors to the risks associated with running a business in a foreign country. This can include political instability, economic downturns, and operational challenges specific to the industry and location.
Investment Capital
FPI: Requires less capital upfront. Investors can participate in foreign markets with a relatively small amount of money by purchasing shares of individual companies or exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that provide exposure to a basket of foreign assets.
FDI: Often involves significant capital outlays. Establishing a new business or acquiring a controlling stake in an existing company can require substantial investment funds. This is why FDI is typically undertaken by large multinational corporations or well-funded private equity firms.
Factors affecting foreign portfolio investments
Foreign investors don’t just throw darts at a map when deciding where to invest their money. Several key factors are carefully weighed before committing capital to a foreign market:
Economic growth prospects: A strong and growing economy is like a magnet for foreign investors. They’re drawn to markets where companies are expanding, profits are rising, and the overall economic outlook is bright. Conversely, sluggish economic growth or signs of recession can trigger an exodus of foreign capital as investors seek greener pastures elsewhere.
Sovereign risk refers to the risk that a government might default on its debts. Foreign investors assess this risk using sovereign ratings issued by independent agencies. Countries with high sovereign ratings are seen as safer bets, attracting greater investment in government bonds and other debt instruments.
Interest rates: Just like anyone else, foreign investors are looking for a good return on their investment. Countries with higher interest rates offer a more attractive proposition, as investors can earn a greater return on their invested capital. This can lead to increased demand for a country’s bonds and other interest-bearing securities.
Tax rates: High taxes can eat into potential profits. Foreign investors are naturally drawn to countries with lower tax rates, as this allows them to keep a larger share of their returns. This can be a significant factor, especially for long-term investments.
Exchange rates: Foreign portfolio investment involves two currencies: the investor’s home currency and the currency of the country they’re investing in. Fluctuations in exchange rates can impact the overall return on investment. A strong foreign currency relative to the investor’s home currency can generate additional gains, while a weakening currency can lead to losses. Excessive exchange rate volatility can also create uncertainty, making some investors hesitant to invest.
Benefits of foreign portfolio investment
Foreign portfolio investment (FPI) isn’t just beneficial for investors seeking international exposure; it also offers significant advantages for destination countries:
Source of loanable funds: FPI acts as a vital injection of capital for developing economies. When foreign investors buy corporate bonds, companies gain access to funds for expansion projects, research and development, or even acquisitions. Similarly, government bond purchases help finance public infrastructure projects like roads, bridges, and power grids. This investment in infrastructure creates a more attractive environment for future business activity, fostering a cycle of growth.
Economic growth catalyst: Foreign capital acts as a fuel for economic expansion. Increased investment can lead to job creation, higher wages, and a rise in overall economic output. Additionally, foreign investors often bring with them valuable knowledge and expertise, which can boost the productivity and competitiveness of domestic companies.
Portfolio diversification for investors: The beauty of FPI lies in its ability to help investors spread risk and enhance returns. By investing in a variety of foreign assets across different countries and sectors, investors can reduce their exposure to any single market downturn. This diversification allows them to potentially achieve higher overall returns with a lower level of risk compared to solely focusing on their domestic market.
Potential for exchange rate gains: Currency fluctuations can add an extra layer of return for foreign investors. If the exchange rate of the destination country strengthens relative to the investor’s home currency, they can enjoy additional profits when converting their investment gains (capital gains, dividends) back into their home currency. This potential for currency appreciation adds another incentive for foreign investment.
However, it’s important to remember that currency fluctuations can also lead to losses if the exchange rate weakens. Investors need to carefully consider the potential impact of exchange rates when making foreign portfolio investment decisions.
Risks of foreign portfolio investments
While foreign portfolio investment (FPI) offers a wealth of benefits, it’s not without its risks. Both foreign investors and destination countries need to be aware of the potential downsides:
Risks for investors
Short-term volatility: FPI’s short-term nature makes it susceptible to sudden market swings. Investors can face significant losses if they’re forced to sell their holdings during a market downturn. This is especially true in developing countries where markets may be less stable and more prone to rapid fluctuations.
Exchange rate fluctuations: Currency movements can significantly impact investment returns. A weakening foreign currency relative to the investor’s home currency can erode profits or even lead to losses when converting investments back into their home currency. This currency risk adds another layer of complexity for foreign investors.
Political instability: Political upheaval or changes in government policies can create an uncertain environment for foreign investors. Investors may be hesitant to commit capital to countries with a history of political unrest or unpredictable leadership. Additionally, sudden policy changes could negatively impact the value of their investments.
Limited control: Unlike FDI, FPI offers minimal control over the underlying investments. Investors have little influence on the management decisions of companies they invest in through stocks and bonds. This lack of control can be a concern for some investors who prefer a more active role in their investments.
Risks for destination countries
Sudden capital flight: FPI’s short-term focus can lead to sudden capital outflows if investors perceive a more attractive opportunity elsewhere or sense economic instability in the host country. This rapid withdrawal of funds can cause exchange rate depreciation, making imports more expensive and potentially triggering a financial crisis.
Limited impact on the real economy: While FPI provides a source of capital, it may not always translate directly into increased productivity or job creation. This is because foreign portfolio investors are primarily focused on short-term financial returns, not necessarily long-term economic development in the host country.
Asset price bubbles: A surge of foreign investment can inflate asset prices, particularly in stock markets. This can create unsustainable bubbles that eventually burst, leading to sharp market corrections and economic hardship.
